By Ventura Research Team 3 min Read
RBI Faces New Questions Over YES Bank AT1 Bond Controversy
Share

Summary:

The RBI and YES Bank have challenged the Supreme Court ruling overturning the ₹8,415 crore AT1 bond write-down. The review petitions could shape bondholder rights, bank-resolution frameworks, capital adequacy and how future banking crises are managed.

The legal battle over YES Bank’s Additional Tier-1 (AT1) bonds worth ₹8,415 crore is set for another turn. The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) and the bank have filed review petitions against the Supreme Court order of October 15, 2026 which struck down the bond write-down. The dispute raises larger questions about how troubled banks can absorb losses in financial crises.

What is the YES Bank AT1 Bond issue?

YES Bank (NSE: YESBANK | BSE: 532648) had been facing a deep financial crisis in March 2020, which led to regulatory intervention and a reconstruction plan.

One part of the rescue was the writing down of ₹8,415 crore of AT1 bonds to zero permanently. The bonds were issued in two tranches of ₹3,000 crore in December 2016 and ₹5,415 crore in October 2017.

Bondholders contested the decision and in January 2023 the Bombay High Court overturned the write-down. The Supreme Court upheld that ruling on Oct. 15, 2026.

The judgment did not invalidate the general loss-absorbing mechanism of AT1 bonds, but focused on the power of the administrator to cancel the bonds after the reconstruction scheme had taken effect.

Why RBI is asking for a review?

AT1 bonds are perpetual debt instruments meant to boost banks’ regulatory capital. Unlike normal fixed income securities, they can absorb losses in a situation of severe financial stress of the bank.

Their main characteristics are:

  • No date of maturity.
  • Coupon payments are at the discretion of and subject to certain conditions.
  • Potential for principal write-down or conversion in case of financial distress.
  • More risky than senior debt and regular bank deposits.

In November 2026, the RBI filed a review petition expressing concern about the implications of the ruling for future bank rescues.

The critical issue is whether the judgment would diminish the use of capital instruments as a buffer to absorb losses before public money or other rescue action is required.

The judgment, however, does stress on the need to respect the approved reconstruction scheme and the exercise of the regulatory powers within the parameters of law.

How Will Ruling Affect YES Bank’s Numbers?

The bank's latest quarterly results showed an improvement in its core business.

YES Bank Q2FY27 results:

FinancialsQ2FY27
Net profit₹1,080 crore
Net profit growth+65% YoY
Net interest income₹2,822 crore
NII growth+22.7% YoY
Gross NPA ratio1.2%
Net NPA ratio0.2%

The financial impact of the judgment of the Supreme Court was not included in the reported results. The ultimate accounting and capital impact will therefore depend on future regulatory and legal developments.

The trustee for the bonds is also asking for the securities to be put back. Questions remain on coupon payments, recognition of liabilities and implementation of the judgment.

Why did YES Bank shares fall after the verdict?

Shares of YES Bank fell around 10% on 15 October, 2026 after Supreme Court’s order with reports of deeper fall in intraday trading.

The fall reflected uncertainty about the possible financial cost of restoring the AT1 bonds and the impact on the bank's capital position.

The legal proceedings were ongoing but the stock recovered some of its losses in November. The bank had filed its review petition on November 13 and the RBI confirmed its review proceedings on November 16.

What’s next?

This is no longer just about the balance sheet of one bank. The resolution of the case could affect the design of AT1 instruments, the implementation of recapitalisation plans and the allocation of losses in future banking crises.

What happens next in the case depends on the outcome of the review petitions, how any outstanding bonds are dealt with and any financial adjustments that may result.

The bigger question for the banking system is: how to maintain effective loss absorption mechanisms, while giving legal certainty to investors.

Please enter a valid name.

+91

Please enter a valid mobile number.

Enable WhatsApp notifications

Verify your mobile number

We have sent an OTP to +91 9876543210

The OTP you entered is invalid. Please try again.

0:60s

Resend OTP

Hold tight, we'll reach out to you the moment we're ready.
+91
Offer Banner Trigger
Offer Banner

Open a FREE Demat Account

+91